The Hurdle of Replacement Cost Value (RCV) to Building Back Better
- Emily Stock, lawyer, Monaghan Reain Lui Taylor LLP
When we discuss the concept of building back better, we all agree that it is great. Who can oppose making our communities, infrastructure and people more resilient to catastrophes. We also recognize that there are a multitude of hurdles to consider, and that underlying many of those hurdles is an often inflexible legal regime.
Understanding property insurance coverages is significant to any policy for building back better. Typically property insurance policies provide for some combination of Actual Cash Value and Replacement Cost Value, depending on a variety of criteria.
Actual Cash Value (ACV) is also sometimes referred to as market value. It is intended to be the dollar amount you could expect to receive for the item if you sold it in the marketplace. It thus takes into account depreciation of the property. An insurance company determines the depreciation based on a combination of objective criteria (a formula considering the category and age) and a subjective assessment in the marketplace. The result is that if a homeowner receives ACV they technically receive exactly what they lost (i.e. the value of an old house); however they cannot afford to replace their property (i.e. build a new house).
Replacement Cost Value (RCV) is the cost to replace the property. It insures the depreciation of the property, so that the homeowner receives the cost to build a new house similar to the house they lost. When we talk about building back better, the homeowner can typically only afford to rebuild if they are able to obtain RCV.
The difficulty in obtaining RCV is that it is typically only available where the rebuild is:
(a) at the same site or location; and,
(b) uses materials of “like kind and quality.”
But what if being at the same location, or building the like kind and quality, is not building back better? Consider if the insured event is a flood in an area that is now prone to flood zones. We don’t want to encourage that homeowner to rebuild in the same location, despite there being significant financial incentive for them to do so. Similarly if the event is a fire, we know that we don’t want to require that the rebuild use the same non-fire resistance materials (i.e. siding, roofing materials), or even to rebuild the same type of structure which may have been inappropriate for the location recognizing the changing environment.
Although we recognize that the wording of the policy must define the rights of the homeowner, and the monetary obligation of the insurer, I expect we would also agree that it seems unfair to require the homeowner to rebuild at the same site, or use materials of like kind and quality, where such is contrary to the principles of building back better.
In considering this conundrum, it is helpful to consider the rationale for RCV, as recently articulated by the Ontario Court of Appeal in Carter v. Intact. After recognizing that replacement cost insurance is justifiable even though it provides the policyholder with greater value than what they lost, the Court explained the following as to why the limitations on RCV are reasonable and required:
… allowing insureds to replace old with new raises a concern for the insurance industry. The concern is moral hazard: the possibility that insureds will intentionally destroy their property in order to profit from their insurance; or the possibility that insureds will be careless about preventing insured losses because they will be better off financially after a loss.
To put a brake on moral hazard, insurers will typically only offer replacement cost coverage if insureds actually repair or replace their damaged or destroyed property. If they do not, they will receive only the actual cash value of their insured property.
It is clear from this reasoning that there is little to no risk of the moral hazard in catastrophic insured events. There is similarly no risk of the moral hazard where an insured homeowner does not want to comply with one or both of the criteria to receive RCV, same location and/or like kind and quality, because of a desire to build back better.
As an advocate for encouraging the insurance industry to build back better, we therefore advocate thoughtfully reducing the two criteria for building back better. This could be done proactively by deleting the same location requirement in policies in flood or other risk zones. The like kind and quality criteria should also be carefully examined for certain types of insured events (i.e. fires), so that more appropriate materials can be agreed upon before the event as acceptable under the policy.
An important step to reducing these types of hurdles is to continue and develop the conversation, which I look forward to doing at the CATIQ Canadian Catastrophe Conference in 2018, and beyond.
113 thoughts on “The Hurdle of Replacement Cost Value (RCV) to Building Back Better”
Hello, I enjoy reading all of your article post. I like to write
a little comment to support you.
Stop by my page :: buy-backlinks.rozblog.com
Рекомендуем внимательно прочитать пост, там всегда есть актуальная информация и процесс получения. Фриспины 150 Вейджер 45x. В противном случае вы не сможете забрать свой выигрыш. Maлoвдoмe кaзинo з пpивaбливoю бoнуcнoю пoлтикoю. Программа лояльности своевременность решения возможных проблем, наличие обратной связи, бонусы, проведение акций и турниров плюсы при выборе игорной площадки. Но прежде чем забрать свой выйгрышь, игроку необходимо получить обратно бонус х40 : 100 х 40 4000 ЦЕЛЬ СТАВКИ.
джойказино слотов и бонусов обзор joycasino джой
Hello there! This article could not be written any better!
Looking at this article reminds me of my previous roommate!
He constantly kept preaching about this. I most certainly will
send this information to him. Fairly certain he’ll have a good read.
I appreciate you for sharing!
Final yea we donated a total oof $9 million to neighborhood nonprofit organizations inside the communities we serve.
Feel free to visit my webpage … 룸싸롱 알바
The most typical drug class for individuaqls attempting to
reduced cholesterol will be statin drugs.
Here is my web page – 스웨디시
magnificent put up, very informative. I wonder why the
other experts of this sector do not understand this. You must continue your writing.
I’m sure, you have a huge readers’ base already!
Fabulous, whаt а blog іt is! This webpage presentѕ valuable infοrmation to
us, keeⲣ it uρ.
Looҝ аt my web blog slot online
Nonetheless, there are btting strategies that can be employed in an edfort
to maximize your edge over on the net casinos.
My web site :: https://slot4u2free.com
Players whoo bet $50+ on their initially wager
wil obtain $111 in website credit.
Alsoo vsit my webpage … more info
The greatest contender iss MetaSpins, where youu
can cash out in 24 hours or significantly less.
my website; homepage
Dordell left first, did some investigation, and
then received a solicitation email about a franchising chance.
my web blog :: 밤일알바
First off I want to say wonderful blog! I had a quick question that I’d like to ask if you do
not mind. I was curious to find out how you
center yourself and clear your mind prior to writing.
I’ve had difficulty clearing my mind in getting my thoughts out.
I do take pleasure in writing however it just seems
like the first 10 to 15 minutes tend to be lost simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas
or tips? Many thanks!
Stop by my blog: xxx
Incredible! This blog looks exactly like my old one!
It’s on a entirely different topic but it has pretty much the same page layout and design.
Outstanding choice of colors!
I loved as much as you will receive carried out right
here. The sketch is attractive, your authored material stylish.
nonetheless, you command get bought an shakiness over that you wish be delivering the following.
unwell unquestionably come further formerly again since exactly the same nearly very
often inside case you shield this hike.
Heya i am for the first time here. I found this board and I find It really useful
& it helped me out much. I hope to give something back and help
others like you helped me.
Nevertheless, some component-time jobs need Social Stats to be at a specific Rank.
Feel free to visit my website; 유흥업소 알바
I аlways սsed to гead post in news papers bսt now as I am a user
of web tһus from now I am սsing net for posts, thanks to
Loоk into my site game casino
Or, opt for the Fourr Hands Thai Massage, a definitely indulgent experience that will leave you feeling refreshed aand revitalized.
Also visit my webb site – 울산 스웨디시
What an cool site!
Is it okay I copy this and share it with my site members?
Come check my channel! It is about Korean 모델출사
If you are interested, feel free to come to my blog and have
Thank you and Continue with the fantastic work!
Thanks very nice blog!
ᒪoοk аt my website … 바카라천국
If some one wants to be updated with newest technologies then he must be pay a quick visit this web site and be up to date every day.
Online slot machines, blackjack, poker, roulette, reside casino games (like Andar Bahar), jusst to name a couple of.
Also visit my homepage – 바카라사이트
Polikce determined that Soutfh Koreans nationals had also received higher compensation for
assisting the group.
Here is myy homepage :: 우리카지노
Greetings! Very useful advice within this post! It’s the little changes
that will make the greatest changes. Thanks for sharing!
Here is my web-site … online marketing
It quickly won an injunction to gather an average of KRW 86.four million ($76,000) that it had paid to every
Visit my webpage: 여성유흥알바
For starters, an employee can elect to defer part of their
salary on a pre-tax basis to a private account, opic to generous limits.
Feeel free to surf to my web-site :: 텐프로 알바
Thiss iss terrific modality for athletes, consumers recovering from injury, and geriatric customers.
Here is my blog :: 스웨디시 1인샵
You hhave to ensure you can get your wins aand deposit/withdraw dollars very easily.
Stop by my web-site – 메이저카지노사이트
Some countries ony have a sset quantity of operating vacation visas to distribute each year.
Heere is myy web page: 여성알바
When youu use the promo ccode “BTCSWB750” on your very fiorst BTC deposit, you’ll qualify for a 75% bonus match upp to $750.
Stop by my website … 온라인카지노추천
Besides, there is a separate reside casino section exactly
where you can wager on European roukette and blackjack.
Feel freee to visit my page: 온라인바카라
Right here is a list of the major Korean companies to help with youhr own search.
Feeel free to surf to mmy blog; 미수다알바
There is a rather steepp turnover requirement you need
to fulfill as component of the welcome bonus terms.
My web-site get more info
The Korean Criminal Code and the Speculative Acts Regulation Act also apply to
games wityh speculative components.
Also visit my homepage – bobtamboli.com
Thanks for the marvelous posting! I seriously
enjoyed reading it, you might be a great author.
I will remember to bookmark your blog and will come back later in life.
I want to encourage you to definitely continue your great posts,
have a nice holiday weekend!
Feel free to visit my homepage … cost
Situated on the 6F of LOTTE HOTEL JEJU, LOTTE Casino is
sprawled over a total region of two,574 square
Stop by my blog :: 우리카지노
Perhaps you’re seeking for jobs hough studying in any Korean university.
Also visit mmy web blog – webpage
The app doesn’t charge interest when you choose the spend-in-4 option, and there
are no costs if you spend oon time.
Have a look at my homepage; 신용대출
With the energy of the online, you can open your own business with juet
Heere is my web-site: bar알바
Now, customers of SoftGamings will be able to access the total game library of Gaming Corps.
Here iis my web site: web page
Blackjack, roulette, baccarat, and Super six are
among the live dealker games accessible.
Also visit my homepage: 온라인카지노추천
From 2006 till 2013, she was a staff writer at The United Methodist Reporter, a newspaper that shut down.
Feel free to surf to my page :: 여성 알바
I used to be suggested this web site by my cousin. I’m no longer sure whether
or not this submit is written by way of him
as no one else know such particular approximately my
trouble. You are wonderful! Thank you!
Upon graduation, you are assured a profession as an Army Officer.
Here is my web site: webpage
Collectively, this powerhouse body oil replenishes skin, locks
in moisture and performs towards toning skin and relaxing muscles.
my blog post: 스웨디시 아로마
Interest prices range from 7.99% to 29.99%, depending
on your credit score.
Also visit my site … 무직자대출
Quick working hours, nice neighborhood, fantastic vacation, furthedr bonus for certified teachers.
Have a look at my web site :: 미수다
Alternatively, you can deposit as little as $20 if makoing use of Bitcoin and nevertheless qualify.
Here is my site webpage
Holders of extreme jobs indicated what motivates thdm
to operate long, stressful hours.
Also vvisit my web site … 유흥업소알바
In most situations, a schedule that falls below what the organization defines as complete-time work is part-time function.
Here is my web site webpage
Grosjean argued that iit really is the structure of gender culture interacting with previously existing finnancial
structures that causes inequalioties to persist.
Viit my web page … 여성 알바
There is no cap on the working hours throughout weekends and vacations.
Revieww my website: 바 알바
A excellent exercise can be tension-relieving, in particular combined with a soothin massage.
My webpage – 스웨디시
New players signing up can claim a welcome bonus of
up to £100, with thee 40x wagering specifications creating profiting from this promotion realistic.
Visit my homepage – web page
Rouynding out our top five Michigsn onn line casinos and sports betting web-sites
my page :: http://www.forderm.net
Hi there, just wanted to tell you, I liked this blog post.
It was funny. Keep on posting!
In England the mystic Mrgery Kempe ran a brewery and later a horse
mill, employing horses to grind corn.
Alsso visit mmy blog post :: 텐카페 알바
You actually mentioned that effectively.
Here is my website … https://studydance.me/2023/02/28/cbogaming-daftar-situs-slot-online-terpercaya-2023/
Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your
articles? I mean, what you say is valuable and everything.
But think about if you added some great photos or videos to give your posts more, “pop”!
Your content is excellent but with images and videos, this site
could certainly be one of the greatest in its field. Great blog!
Feel free to surf to my web blog … Will Bitcoin lose value
when all is mined? (Jerri)
As per IANS report, the criminals had been arrested in separate raids in Delhi, Gururam
and Fatehabad (Haryana) in this connection.
My homepage; 유흥알바
In this overview, we will discover the capabilities that set
MyBookie Casino apart from its competitors.
Have a look at my web site – 온라인카지노
An additional area it pprovides other casinos in Montana a run for tyeir funds is with its
My webpage: website
A hagwon is fundamentally a “cram” school exactly where students go right after chool for English classes.
Review my website 여성알바
Disney executives have toldd Wall Street that overcoming increases in labor charges wilol
be crucial to expanding profit margins in tthe paris and resorts division.
Take a loook at my webpage 업소 알바
One of the biggest gambling brands in thhe globe, 888
has got a good esports sportsbook.
My homepage … more info
You will come across all your favourites, such as pokies, table
games, aand more.
Here is my web-site: click here
Our on-line map maker makes it straightforward to import any list, spreadsheet, or geodata.
Also visit my web bpog – 리플파워볼
The enterprise was established in 1996, at the ooutset
off the revolution in online gaming.
Stopp by my web-site; homepage
Wow, superb blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is wonderful, as well as
You also can not receive more than 50% of the month-to-month advantage your spouse collects.
my blog post 비제이알바
The reading for discouraged job seekers diminished 190,000
to 425,000 in the cited month.
Here is my blog 이지알바
To use a bonus code, just type the codxe in when prompted by the casiino web site.
Know that there are rights for all workers in South Korea, which
includes factory and agricultural workers.
Alsoo visit my page; bar알바
Its like you learn my thoughts! You appear to understand so much approximately this, like you wrote
the e book in it or something. I believe that you simply can do with a few percent to
power the message house a bit, but instead of that, that is excellent blog.
A great read. I will definitely be back.https://www.jp-dolls.com/
I’ll immediately snatch your rss as I can not in finding your e-mail subscription hyperlink or newsletter service.
Do you have any? Please let me recognize in order
that I may subscribe. Thanks.
As responsibilities for girls increased at dwelling, thgey also faced growing uncertainty
in the workplace.
Here is my page … 텐카페 알바
По каким причинам требуется ремонт административных зданий. Ремонт нежилых помещений может быть необходим по целому ряду причин. Это может быть износ, уменьшение характеристик и увеличение показателей износа, трансформация дизайна и планировки, несоответствие требованиям органов государственного регулирования по уровню отделки и т.д. Самые важные моменты, которые требуют ремонта зданий, это снижение санэпидемических норм, снижение его функциональности, потеря тепла и прочее.
Само собой разумеется, что без соответствующих компетенций выполнить ремонт такого уровня очень сложно. По мимо этого. существуют разнообразные нормы и законодательства, которые нужно соблюдать при ремонте зданий. Кроме того, когда речь идет о коммерческих помещениях, которые будут использоваться для общения с клиентами, стиль, цветовая гамма и качество отделки имеют не меньшее значение, поскольку первоначальное впечатление о компании должно быть профессиональным.
Виды ремонтов. Косметический ремонт не включает в себя какие то перепланировки, он лишь подразумевает обновление того что есть, косметический ремонт зданий, самый минимальный. В отличие от него, капитальный ремонт предполагает полную перепланировку помещения, часто с частичной перестройкой и заменой окон, дверей и других элементов https://mettem-ct.ru/ – ремонт медицинского центра в Москве
Такой тип ремонта как творческий. Элитная инициатива с включением декораторов, творцов, профи по стеклу, камню и т.д. Как правило, в орнаментации используются компоненты корпоративного имиджа фирмы. Косметический макияж все чаще выполняется силами заказчика. Более серьезный уход требует участия провайдера, входящего в состав sro. При подготовке схемы масштабного ремонта, реконструкции или перепланировки также целесообразно обратиться к организации, входящей в sro.
Также существует косметический ремонт без заявок на капитальный, но с некоторыми переделками, которые не подразумевают собой участие кадастровых служб. Чтобы работа была выполнена правильно, важно спланировать последовательность задач в правильном порядке. Начните с дизайн-проекта, затем перейдите к прокладке внутренних коммуникаций и черновой отделке. Наконец, можно завершить работу последними штрихами, такими как меблировка и расстановка офисного оборудования.
Критерии качества гласят, что восстановление любого объекта коммерческой недвижимости должно занимать не более 5 лет. Это помогает поддерживать приятную атмосферу, точно контролировать бюджеты на амортизацию и быстро проводить регулярное техническое обслуживание без ущерба для деятельности компании. Каждое коммерческое здание ремонтируется в первую очередь для того чтобы сохранить свою респектабельность для тех людей, которые его посещают.
Ремонт коммерческих и административных зданий должен происходить качественно и максимально быстро, потому как просой таких помещений и сооружений ведет к потери прибыли. Поэтому сроки ремонта административного здания очень важны при его планировании.
But make confident to check that tthe web-site is not restricted in your country, even even though Ethereum is.
Take a lookk at my page: 바카라사이트
Truly a lot of beneficial material.
my web blog … https://Studydance.me/2023/02/28/cbogaming-kumpulan-situs-judi-slot-online-terbaik-dan-terpercaya-bet-kecil/
Apple does noot sjop or have access to the original credit, debit, or prepaid card numbers
that yyou use with Apple Spend.
Feel free to surf to my webpage 힘쎈공
It’s an awesome article in support of all the internet visitors;
they will get advantage from it I am sure.
In contyrast to paper tickets, the digital realm gives far more insight on understanding oon fans.
Also visit my site 엔트리파워볼
How do you find a job iin South Korea when you graduate iif
you are an international student?
Also visit my site … 단란주점 알바
An employee can operate added hours to compensate
for perform missed rather than use earnedd sick leave, with the employer’s consent.
Here is my web site 미수다알바
Мусорные мешки – это важный элемент в современном домашнем уборе. Они позволяют собирать мусор и сохранять его в безопасности до тех пор, пока его не утилизируют. Кроме того, использование мусорных мешков имеет еще ряд других польз.
Во-первых, мусорные мешки облегчают процесс уборки, позволяя быстро собирать мусор в одном месте. Они защищают поверхности от загрязнения и способствуют тому, что помещение остается более чистым.
Во-вторых, мусорные мешки гигиенически и безопасны. Они помогают предотвращать распространение бактерий и грибков, которые могут вызвать различные заболевания. Благодаря высокой прочности и качественному материалу, мусорные мешки не рвутся и не течут, что позволяет собирать отходы безопасным для человека способом.
мешки под мусор большие
An on the nett lending platform named BadCreditLoans assists borrowers gget
Chck out my homepage … 프리랜서 대출
Interest prices and terms depend on how creditworthy you are, but they range from 9.95 percent to 35.99 %.
my blog post: web site
Havikng additional funds in your account increases your
probabilities oof winning.
my web page … somek.ktwiki.com
At Virgin Casino, we’re all about bringing your on the neet casino experience to a new level.
Feel free to vsit my page: get more info
These are in fact wonderful ideas in about blogging.
You have touched some pleasant points here. Any way keep up wrinting.
Aside from jackpots, a few also give bonuses and other prizes.
Here is my blog – 동행복권 파워볼
Ԝhat’s ᥙp to eνery one, since Ι am truly keen of reading
tһis blog’s post to be updated regularly. Ιt carries fastidious material.
mү web page; lotto
Caesars has ensured tha you get the ighest high-quality in gameplay with their higher performing app and
deskotop web page.
Here is my site: 온라인카지노추천
As a result, numerous players opt to use this process when funding their casino
Also visit my website :: 메이저카지노사이트
Trident’s securities aare listed on the Nasdaq stock exchange below the ticker symbols TDACU,
TDAC annd TDACW.
Also visit my homepage – 보글파워볼
This comes down to the betting web-site itself and the payment process that you are employing.
my blog; http://ttlink.com/marvinolso/all
разработка сайта беларусь
For instance, you’re operating 25 hours a
week on a pro rata basis.
Stop byy my web page … 미수다
As legislation becomes clarified federally, states will make thei
perfsonal choices in this arena.
My website … site
In truth, despite its name, Slots.LV has much less than 200 slot
gamws iin total.
my webpage :: yrmll.tribunablog.com
Payout iss the percentage of funds (“winnings”) returned
Review my webpage :: click here
BitStaz is one of the bestBitcoin casinos, and its welxome bonus completely reflects that.
Here is my webb site: 카지노사이트추천
Do you have a spam issue on this website; I also am a blogger, and I was curious
about your situation; we have developed some nice methods and we are looking to exchange methods with others, why not shoot me an email if interested.
“The typical cost oof assisted living facilities is $4,500 per
month,” states Chris.
Also visit my web page 유흥알바
The increases for Seoul and Gwangju have been four.six percentage points and three.1 percdentage points, respectively.
Checfk out my blog post; 업소알바
The PA Lottery has committed to expanding into other actual-planet
drawing games and keno.
Reviww my site: VG보글파워볼
This is operated annd self-regulated by the Japanese government, oor municipal
bodies whre permitted.
Here is mmy website cleanhasugu.co.kr
Clarins Head of Coaching, Marje Schmid uses the Clarins Contour Physique
Oil to give lyymphatic draihage massages to her customers.
Feel free to surf to my web-site – 마사지
This is commonly the case unless there’s a greater-than-typical number of requests.
Feel free to visit my web page: get more info
The King of Bonuses in the UK is the King of Promotions in the US.
my website website
These reports include detailed business analysis, marketplace size, share, growth drivers, and
my web-site website
You can apply for loan amounts at CashUSA, ranging from $500 to $ten,000.
Here is my blog; 전당포 대출
This would give the brand farr more access to nations like Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand.
my web-site: 스웨디시마사지